Re: transpose fails to transpose the pitchedTrill notehead

[David Kastrup]

Arnold <address@hidden> writes:

>> I'm not top posting.
>
> Hello, the trill note head (resp. pitch) of a pitchedTrill is no longer 
> transposed (as in 2.14.2).
> Tested on a Win7/64 Computer.
>
> \version "2.15.36"
> { \transpose c as' { \pitchedTrill e'4\startTrillSpan fis' r\stopTrillSpan } }

New issue 2484
Patch: Let pitched trills in articulations be transposed as well
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2484

It turns out that the example file
\version "2.15.34"
\new Voice
{ \transpose c as' { \pitchedTrill e'4\startTrillSpan fis' r\stopTrillSpan }
                   { \pitchedTrill e'4\startTrillSpan fis' r\stopTrillSpan }
}

still gives a strange result with the fix applied: the first trill pitch
gets an explicit natural accidental even though this would be part of
the surrounding key signature.  Removing \pitchedTrill, \startTrillSpan,
and \stopTrillSpan does not result in similar spurious accidentals, so
it would appear to be an artifact of the pitched trill code.

This is a separate issue, however, and in contrast to your issue not
likely a regression.

-- 
David Kastrup