Re: [Gluster-devel] AFR documentation

[Thierry EXCOFFIER]

Krishna Srinivas wrote:
> >    - If the version numbers are identicals, do you detect that
> >      the file content is not the same ?
>
> No. But we can have improve the safety level to handle such cases
> by further checking if the copies differ by mtime (by more than 30 secs, say)
> or if they have different file sizes etc in which case we can return EIO.
> Again suggestions are welcome.

Can you store the IP of the last client who have modified the file ?
If the version is the same but not the client IP then the file
content is in an inpredictable state.

May be you could assume that if the file is wrote by more than one
client then the *user application* has locked the file before.
In this case you need an option to indicate to AFR that
the file locking succeed only if all the clients are up.

Hope my 2 cents may help.

Thierry.
--
Thierry.EXCOFFIER@@liris.univ-lyon1.fr//   GO: Oriental Strategy Game
LIRIS/UFR Informatique, bat710       //DYLAN: Programming Language
Universite Claude Bernard LYON 1  __// UNIX: Standard Operating System
43 Bd du 11 novembre 1918       //
69622 VILLEURBANNE, FRANCE     //WWW: http://www710.univ-lyon1.fr/~exco