Re: [Gluster-devel] Registering the Gluster RPC protocols and AUTH-flavor at IANA?

[Kaleb Keithley]

From: "Niels de Vos" <address@hidden>
Sent: Tuesday, April 24, 2012 7:11:02 AM>

> At the moment Gluster uses quite some RPC program numbers which are not
> officially registered for Gluster usage.
>
> RFC 5531 (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5531) contains "Appendix B:
> Requesting RPC-Related Numbers from IANA". I think it will be good to
> request program numbers for the different RPC protocols. It should even be
> possible to serve two program numbers at the same time, keeping compatibility
> between minor releases, but at the same time prepare for the switch.
>
> Thoughts?

I'm not sure we would solve anything by registering them.

Unlike NFS, where we run on non-standard ports, using registered prognums and 
progvers lets us advertise via portmapper to clients what port(s) to use for 
mountd, nfs, and nlm services.

If we ever intend to run glusterd on a port other than 24007, and advertise 
through portmapper, then I could imagine there would be some value in 
registering our prognums and progvers.

But we don't advertise in portmapper, and AFAIK, we're not planning to use any 
port other than 24007 (and 24009+)

I presume we've registered port 24007 at least with IANA. If not, we should.

--

Kaleb