Re: [Gluster-devel] [vdsm] How to figure out the transport type of Gluster volume from VDSM host (which is not a gluster peer) ?

[Shu Ming]

2013-5-6 22:33, Deepak C Shetty:
> Hi Lists,
>     I am looking at options to figure the transport type of a gluster 
> volume (given the volfileserver:volname) from a host that is *not* 
> part of gluster volume (aka not a gluster peer).
>
> The context here is GlusterFS as a storage domain in oVirt/VDSM, which 
> is currently available in upstream oVirt.
> This features exploits the QEMU-GlusterFS native integration, where 
> the VM disk is specified using gluster+<transport>://... protocol.
>
>     For eg. if transport is TCP.. the URI looks liek 
> gluster+tcp://..., otherwise gluster+rdma://...
>
> Thus, to generate the gluster QEMU URI in VDSM, i need to know the 
> Gluster volume's transport type and the only inputs that oVirt gets 
> for GlusterFS storage domain are...
> a) volfileserver (the host running glusterd)
> b) volname (the name of the volume)
>
> Currently i use VDSM's gluster plugin to do the eq. of "gluster volume 
> info <volname>" to determine Gluster volume's transport type, but this 
> won't work if the VDSM host is not a gluster peer, 
What do you mean by using "gluster peer"?  Does "gluster peer" mean the 
host is running glusterd?

> which is a constraint! ... and I would like to fix/remove this 
> constraint.
>
> So i discussed a bit on #glsuter-dev IRC and want to put down the 
> options here for the community to help provide inputs on whats the 
> best way to approach this...
>
> 1) Use gluster --remote-host=<host_running_glusterd> volume info 
> <volname>
>
> This is not a supported way and there is no guarantee on how long the 
> --remote-host option be supported in gluster, since it has some 
> security issues
>
> 2) Use gluster ::system getspec <volname>
>
> I tried this but it never worked for me... whats the right way of 
> using this ?
> For me.. it just returned back to shell w/o dumping the volfile at all!
>
> 3) Have oVirt user provide the transport type as well (while creating 
> Gluster storgae domain) in addition to volfileserver:volname options
>
> This would be easiest, since VDSM can form the gluster QEMU URI by 
> directly using the transport type specified by the user, and this 
> won't have a need to use the vdsm-gluster plugin, hence no need for 
> VDSM host to be part of gluster peer...but this would mean addnl input 
> for user to provide during Gluster domain creation and oVirt UI 
> changes to take the transport type as input in addition to 
> volfileserver:volname
What will happen if a user gives a wrong transport type to VDSM?

> Comments/Opinions/Inputs appreciated
>
> thanx,
> deepak
>
> (P.S. cross-posting this to VDSM and Gluster devel lists, as it 
> relates to both)
>
> _______________________________________________
> vdsm-devel mailing list
> address@hidden
> https://lists.fedorahosted.org/mailman/listinfo/vdsm-devel


--
---
舒明 Shu Ming
Open Virtualization Engineerning; CSTL, IBM Corp.
Tel: 86-10-82451626  Tieline: 9051626 E-mail: address@hidden or address@hidden
Address: 3/F Ring Building, ZhongGuanCun Software Park, Haidian District, 
Beijing 100193, PRC