Re: [gnugo-devel]GNU Go-HT [was Re:GNU Go 3.5.3]

[max-d]

----- Original Message -----
From: <address@hidden>
To: "GNU Go development" <address@hidden>
Cc: <address@hidden>
Sent: Monday, January 12, 2004 6:24 PM
Subject: Re: [gnugo-devel] Re:GNU Go 3.5.3



> The cosmic option was only turned on by default for one release,
> namely 3.5.1. This release coincided with GNU Go's decline on
> NNGS (except the first precipitous drop, which came during 3.4).
> The rating started to recover immediately after 3.5.2 was put out.
>
> You can still get cosmic GNU Go as a configure or command line
> option. It gives a style that tries to build moyos in the center
> but you have to be really strong like Takemiya to play such a style.
> Cosmic GNU Go builds moyos that are full of holes and easy to break up.

Reading this , i'm afraid my comments were not understandable (as usual,
sorry!)...
I just think Cosmic did well vs go++ but i don't like it for the same
reasons You and Gunnar pointed out.
I also think (i said) that 5.3.3-no cosmic tends to adopt some
cosmic-like  fuseki style .
Btw , i also said in my previous post that HT is a useful tool to reveal
GNU Go mistakes and also that it should be possible to have GNU Go
scoring 100% against HT.
Saying that , i omited to add that revealing mistakes is not a big deal ,
fixing them being an other thing  !
(I don't even ignore that)

In anycase ,and waiting  for GNU Go 4.x.x to score 100%
here are the final test results

GNUGO_353 95
HANDTALK 52

65%  (gg 3.4 got 54%)

= _GNUGO_353 won:
2 (67)
5 (13)
6 (16)
7 (79)
8 (53)
9 (55)
12 (4)
13 (26)
15 (18)
17 (32)
18 (58)
20 (62)
21 (13)
22 (62)
24 (4)
26 (5)
27 (69)
29 (32)
31 (42)
32 (40)
34 (34)
35 (62)
41 (82)
42 (44)
43 (48)
44 (33)
45 (7)
46 (23)
48 (15)
51 (61)
52 (53)
53 (31)
55 (51)
56 (55)
57 (15)
58 (15)
59 (26)
60 (33)
61 (45)
62 (28)
63 (19)
64 (64)
66 (20)
67 (49)
68 (40)
69 (32)
70 (24)
72 (1)
73 (47)
76 (52)
77 (39)
80 (9)
82 (11)
84 (83)
85 (33)
86 (55)
87 (54)
90 (54)
92 (1)
94 (4)
95 (55)
97 (9)
98 (44)
99 (17)
100 (64)
102 (66)
103 (51)
104 (67)
107 (58)
109 (54)
116 (21)
117 (71)
118 (21)
119 (1)
120 (32)
121 (8)
125 (44)
126 (23)
127 (27)
128 (78)
130 (1)
131 (24)
132 (87)
134 (1)
135 (21)
136 (42)
137 (62)
138 (11)
141 (37)
143 (9)
144 (46)
145 (69)
146 (27)
147 (9)
148 (60)

= HANDTALK won:
1 (18)
3 (1)
4 (6)
10 (6)
14 (7)
16 (11)
19 (7)
23 (41)
25 (11)
28 (7)
30 (7)
33 (14)
36 (38)
37 (25)
38 (100)
39 (29)
40 (23)
47 (18)
49 (63)
50 (15)
54 (25)
65 (0)
71 (47)
74 (1)
75 (84)
78 (41)
79 (12)
81 (15)
83 (13)
88 (16)
89 (22)
91 (43)
93 (49)
96 (50)
101 (41)
105 (59)
106 (21)
108 (21)
110 (9)
111 (34)
112 (27)
113 (14)
114 (44)
115 (2)
122 (4)
123 (8)
124 (9)
129 (25)
133 (3)
139 (14)
140 (8)
142 (14)

>
> Dan
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> gnugo-devel mailing list
> address@hidden
> http://mail.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnugo-devel