Re: caesura or other ornamentation ?.

[Andrew Bernard]

Hi All,

With the understanding that this is long before the age of 
standardisation of anything, and one author's table of ornaments is not 
necessarily what another composer would have, and performers would 
naturally have taken great liberties with interpretation of signs. Not 
until 19c did people become very rigid about ornaments and signs. I 
write speaking as a harpsichord player myself.

As an aside, but related, to this day nobody really has any clear idea 
what the single and double strokes on stems that are ornament signs in 
English Virginal Music really mean. There are dozens of different opinions.

As for whether trills and shakes start on the principal note or not, 
that is an Eternal Debate that will never be resolved.

Isn't there an article here about making new ornaments for noteheads, 
for 18c French music in particular?

https://lilypondblog.org/2013/08/adding-ornamentations-to-note-heads-part-1/


Andrew


On 10/07/2019 1:21 am, Torsten Hämmerle wrote:
> prelleur_treatise_ornaments_1731.png
> <http://lilypond.1069038.n5.nabble.com/file/t3887/prelleur_treatise_ornaments_1731.png>