[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [Freeipmi-users] No SDR values from ipmi-sensors on Fujitsu RX300 an
|
From: |
Olaf Morgenstern |
|
Subject: |
Re: [Freeipmi-users] No SDR values from ipmi-sensors on Fujitsu RX300 and RX300S2 |
|
Date: |
Mon, 19 Sep 2011 10:43:25 +0200 |
I forgot to CC to the list, so this is to make up my mistake...
Hi Al,
thank you for the beta release.
It works!
As you can see in the attached outputs (no cache flush issued before), the
sensors are read fine.
The only difference to version 0.5.1 is the output of the OEM values. But this
values seem to be broken, i.e. sensor IDs 2624 an 2672 say that FAN SYS5 and
FAN PS1 are present, but sensor IDs 1728 and 1792 show a RPM value of 0. In
fact, both fans are not present, because the redundant sys fan option (FAN SYS3
to SYS5) is not built in, and there is only one power supply (the redundant
second power supply PS1 is not built in). If you look at the OEM values for the
SYS and PS fans (IDs 2720, 2768, 2816, 2864, 2912, 2960, 3008, 3056) you can
see different values for the present and the absent ones. But this is not your
problem, it's the Fujitsu BMC/IPMI implementation...
So, "-W assumebmcowner" helps on the old Fujitsu hardware. Tested on RX300 and
RX300S2.
It should work on the following Fujitsu server hardware with the so called
Kalypso-BMC:
– RX200 / TX200 (mainboard D1570 / D1419)
– RX220 (mainboard D2130)
– RX300 / TX300 (mainboard D1409 / D1409)
– RX100 S2 (mainboard D1571)
– RX200 S2 / TX200 S2 (mainboard D1790 / D1919)
– RX300 S2 / TX300 S2 (mainboard D1889/D2089 / D1899/D2099)
– RX100 S3 (mainboard D2004)
– TX150 S2 (mainboard D1751)
– TX150 S3 (mainboard D1979)
– TX150 S4 (mainboard D2239)
Regards,
Olaf
-------- Original-Nachricht --------
> Datum: Thu, 15 Sep 2011 14:17:01 -0700
> Von: Albert Chu <address@hidden>
> An: Olaf Morgenstern <address@hidden>
> CC: "address@hidden" <address@hidden>
> Betreff: Re: [Freeipmi-users] No SDR values from ipmi-sensors on Fujitsu
> RX300 and RX300S2
> Hey Olaf,
>
> Here is a beta release
>
> http://download.gluster.com/pub/freeipmi/qa-release/freeipmi-1.0.7.beta2.tar.gz
>
> In it, ipmi-sensors has a new workaround option called 'assumebmcowner',
> can you see if it works? Just specify:
>
> ipmi-sensors -W assumebmcowner
>
> (longer term, you can configure this workaround in /etc/freeipmi.conf so
> you don't have to type it everytime. But for now ...)
>
> Can you try it and let me know if the workaround works for you.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Al
>
> On Thu, 2011-09-15 at 09:00 -0700, Al Chu wrote:
> > Huh ... but it does work w/ 0.5.1. Ya know, maybe your SDR is just
> > buggy. Even though it advertises that it wants to bridge sensors, in
> > reality, it shouldn't. Back in 0.5.1, ipmi-sensors wasn't as
> > correct/valid, so bridging wasn't handled properly.
> >
> > Let me get you a beta tar.gz with a workaround option to try out and see
> > if that helps.
> >
> > Al
> >
> > On Thu, 2011-09-15 at 04:39 -0700, Olaf Morgenstern wrote:
> > > Hi Al,
> > >
> > > as promised, the debug output from ipmi-sensors v0.5.1, once after a
> cache flush and once from a filled cache. Don't wonder about the different
> IP address, it's still a RX300 which was queried. The reason is that I can't
> query the IPMI LAN interface of the same machine running ipmi-sensors
> (it's a Broadcom LAN interface and BMC).
> > >
> > > Thanks, Olaf
> > >
> > >
> > > -------- Original-Nachricht --------
> > > > Datum: Wed, 14 Sep 2011 07:47:16 -0700
> > > > Von: Al Chu <address@hidden>
> > > > An: "address@hidden" <address@hidden>
> > > > CC: "address@hidden" <address@hidden>
> > > > Betreff: Re: [Freeipmi-users] No SDR values from ipmi-sensors on
> Fujitsu RX300 and RX300S2
> > >
> > > > Hi,
> > > >
> > > > First, could run the following
> > > >
> > > > ipmi-sensors -f
> > > >
> > > > to flush out the old SDR cache and try ipmi-sensors again (it'll
> reload
> > > > the SDR cache). I'm wondering if there was an SDR format change
> between
> > > > versions that is not being caught.
> > > >
> > > > Although I've personally never seen it before, you may want to try
> the
> > > > --bridge-sensors option. It's possible all your motherboard's
> sensors
> > > > aren't owned by the BMC.
> > > >
> > > > If that doesn't work, could you send me the ipmi-sensors output w/
> > > > --debug.
> > > >
> > > > Thanks,
> > > > Al
> > > >
> > > > On Tue, 2011-09-13 at 23:57 -0700, address@hidden wrote:
> > > > > I want to monitor my Fujitsu servers with the check-ipmi-sensor
> plugin
> > > > (v2) for Nagios. It requires the ipmimonitoring tool from freeipmi.
> > > > >
> > > > > I tried the freeipmi version 0.5.1 shipped with CentOS 5.6. OK, it
> is
> > > > really old, but the ipmi-sensors works fine. But the command
> "ipmimonitoring"
> > > > doesn't work - it returns a SDR cache error:
> > > > >
> > > > > address@hidden ~]# ipmimonitoring -h 60.18.18.1 -l user
> > > > > ipmi_monitoring_sensor_readings_by_record_id: internal error
> > > > >
> > > > > If I use the --debug switch, the additional info is:
> > > > >
> > > > > (ipmi_monitoring_sdr_cache.c, _ipmi_monitoring_sdr_cache_retrieve,
> 537):
> > > > ipmi_sdr_cache_complete: incomplete number of records written
> > > > >
> > > > > OK, I assume there will be no support for this old version,
> neither by
> > > > the freeipmi developers or Redhat/CentOS.
> > > > >
> > > > > Next I tried the freeipmi version 0.7.16 shipped with CentOS 6.
> But
> > > > ipmi-sensors or ipmimonitoring doesn't show any SDR values, it
> returns only NA.
> > > > >
> > > > > That's why I have compiled the newest freeipmi 1.0.6 on CentOS
> 5.6.
> > > > > But, surprise, ipmi-sensors doesn't show any SDR values, it
> returns only
> > > > N/A:
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > > (0)address@hidden:
> > > > /home/a18/omo/rpmbuild/BUILD/freeipmi-1.0.6/ipmi-sensors/src $su -c
> "./ipmi-sensors -h 18.18.18.2 -l user"
> > > > > Password:
> > > > > ID | Name | Type | Reading |
> Units |
> > > > Event
> > > > > 0 | Systemboard | Temperature | N/A | C
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 64 | CPU0 | Temperature | N/A | C
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 128 | CPU1 | Temperature | N/A | C
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 192 | Ambient | Temperature | N/A | C
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 256 | PSU | Temperature | N/A | C
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 320 | PSU FanControl | OEM Reserved | N/A | C
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 384 | PSU Power | Current | N/A | W
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 448 | Main +12V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 512 | Main -12V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 576 | Main +5V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 640 | Main 3.3V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 704 | Battery +3V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 768 | Main 2.5V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 832 | Stdby +3.3V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 896 | SSTL_Term | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 960 | Main +1.5V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1024 | VGA +2.5V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1088 | Lan +1.2V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1152 | Lan +2.5V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1216 | SCSI +1.8V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1280 | BMC +2.5V | Voltage | N/A | V
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1344 | FAN SYS0 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1408 | FAN SYS1 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1472 | FAN SYS2 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1536 | FAN PS0 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1600 | FAN SYS3 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1664 | FAN SYS4 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1728 | FAN SYS5 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1792 | FAN PS1 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1856 | FAN CPU0 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1920 | FAN CPU1 | Fan | N/A |
> RPM |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 1984 | SEL Level | Monitor ASIC/IC | N/A | %
> |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2048 | CPU0 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2096 | CPU0 | Processor | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2144 | CPU1 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2192 | CPU1 | Processor | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2240 | PS0 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2288 | PS1 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2336 | FAN SYS0 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2384 | FAN SYS1 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2432 | FAN SYS2 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2480 | FAN PS0 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2528 | FAN SYS3 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2576 | FAN SYS4 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2624 | FAN SYS5 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2672 | FAN PS1 PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2720 | FAN SYS0 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2768 | FAN SYS1 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2816 | FAN SYS2 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2864 | FAN PS0 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2912 | FAN SYS3 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 2960 | FAN SYS4 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3008 | FAN SYS5 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3056 | FAN PS1 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3104 | PS0 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3152 | PS1 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3200 | FAN CPU0 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3248 | FAN CPU1 STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3296 | ACPI Power State | System ACPI Power State | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3344 | Watchdog | Watchdog 2 | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3392 | PSU RED PRSNT | Entity Presence | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3440 | PSU RED STAT | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3488 | PSU status | Power Unit | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 3536 | BMC request | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 4736 | System Mgmt SW | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 4784 | System BIOS | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > 4832 | BMC | OEM Reserved | N/A |
> N/A |
> > > > N/A
> > > > > (0)address@hidden:
> > > > /home/a18/omo/rpmbuild/BUILD/freeipmi-1.0.6/ipmi-sensors/src $su -c
> "./ipmi-sensors -h 18.18.18.2 -l user -s 0 -v"
> > > > > Password:
> > > > > Record ID: 0
> > > > > ID String: Systemboard
> > > > > Sensor Type: Temperature (1h)
> > > > > Sensor Number: 1
> > > > > IPMB Slave Address: 12h
> > > > > Sensor Owner ID: 24h
> > > > > Sensor Owner LUN: 0h
> > > > > Channel Number: 0h
> > > > > Entity ID: system board (7)
> > > > > Entity Instance: 0
> > > > > Entity Instance Type: Physical Entity
> > > > > Event/Reading Type Code: 1h
> > > > > Sensor Min. Reading: -128.000000 C
> > > > > Sensor Max. Reading: 127.000000 C
> > > > > Normal Min.: N/A
> > > > > Normal Max.: N/A
> > > > > Nominal Reading: N/A
> > > > > Sensor Reading: N/A
> > > > > Sensor Event: N/A
> > > > >
> > > > > (0)address@hidden:
> > > > /home/a18/omo/rpmbuild/BUILD/freeipmi-1.0.6/ipmi-sensors/src $
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > > Which information should I provide to track the bug?
> > > > >
> > > > > Kind regards,
> > > > > omo
> > > > >
> > > > > _______________________________________________
> > > > > Freeipmi-users mailing list
> > > > > address@hidden
> > > > > https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/freeipmi-users
> > > > --
> > > > Albert Chu
> > > > address@hidden
> > > > Computer Scientist
> > > > High Performance Systems Division
> > > > Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
> > > >
> --
> Albert Chu
> address@hidden
> Computer Scientist
> High Performance Systems Division
> Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
>
>
- Re: [Freeipmi-users] No SDR values from ipmi-sensors on Fujitsu RX300 and RX300S2,
Olaf Morgenstern <=