Re: Child frame alpha (not background)

[Po Lu]

[Please use "Reply All", so that the mailing list receives all replies.]

Psionic K <psionik@positron.solutions> writes:

> Sounds like the expectation is that applications should composite
> internally if they want to draw more things in a given window.  Given
> that tiling exists, asking for windows but not wanting them managed by
> a window manager seems counter to a user-choice focused data model.

X "windows" are what other toolkits dub "widgets," top-level windows
being windows whose parents are the root window or frame windows created
by a window manager.  A window manager cannot control top-level windows
on which the override-redirect property is set, so such constrants as
tiling cannot be imposed on them.

> If that's true, the right solution is to properly implement a child
> frame that uses drawing rather than repurposing the window
> functionality.

Anyway, patches to this end are welcome as always, but until then frames
will remain sub-optimal as user-interface elements.